January 29, 2023

Jennifer Homendy speaks at a press convention on October 3, 2019 in Windsor Locks, Connecticut. On Wednesday, Homendy, chairperson of the Nationwide Transportation Security Board, stated she was involved concerning the danger posed by heavy electrical autos within the occasion of a collision with lighter autos.

Chris Ehrmann/AP


conceal title

swap title

Chris Ehrmann/AP


Jennifer Homendy speaks at a press convention on October 3, 2019 in Windsor Locks, Connecticut. On Wednesday, Homendy, chairperson of the Nationwide Transportation Security Board, stated she was involved concerning the danger posed by heavy electrical autos within the occasion of a collision with lighter autos.

Chris Ehrmann/AP

DETROIT. On Wednesday, the top of the Nationwide Transportation Security Board raised considerations concerning the security dangers posed by heavy electrical autos in the event that they collide with lighter autos.

Official Jennifer Homendy raised the problem in her speech in Washington earlier than the Transportation Analysis Council. For instance, she famous that an electrical GMC Hummer weighs about 9,000 kilos (4,000 kg) with a battery that weighs 2,900 kilos (1,300 kg) – about the identical as a typical Honda Civic.

“I’m involved concerning the elevated danger of great harm and demise for all highway customers because of the enhance in curb weight and the rise within the measurement, energy and efficiency of autos on our roads, together with electrical autos,” Homendy stated in a speech ready for the group.

The additional weight that electrical autos usually carry is because of the sheer mass of their batteries. To achieve 300 or extra miles (480 or extra kilometers) on a single cost from an electrical car, the batteries should weigh 1000’s of kilos.

Some battery chemistries beneath improvement might pack extra vitality into much less mass. However for now, there’s a weight disparity between electrical autos and smaller inner combustion autos. Electrical autos additionally switch energy immediately to their wheels, inflicting them to speed up quicker than most gas-powered automobiles, vans and SUVs normally.

Homendy stated she was inspired by the Biden administration’s plans to section out carbon emissions from automobiles to cope with the local weather disaster. However she stated she nonetheless worries concerning the security dangers related to the proliferation of electrical autos on roads and highways.

“We’ve got to watch out to not create unintended penalties: extra deaths on our roads,” she stated. “Security, particularly relating to new transport insurance policies and new applied sciences, can’t be neglected.”

Homendy famous that the Ford F-150 Lightning EV pickup is 2,000–3,000 kilos (900 to 1,350 kg) heavier than the interior combustion engine model of the identical mannequin. The Mustang Mach E and Volvo XC40 EV electrical SUVs are about 33% heavier than their petrol counterparts, she stated.

“This has a big affect on the protection of all highway customers,” Homendy added.

The NTSB investigates site visitors accidents however doesn’t have the facility to make guidelines. Within the case of autos, such authority is primarily vested within the Nationwide Freeway Site visitors Security Administration.

Even other than electrical autos, the nation’s roads are crowded with heavy autos due to a decade-long growth in gross sales of huge automobiles, vans and SUVs that has led to excessive disparities in collisions with smaller autos. However electrical autos are usually a lot heavier than even the biggest gasoline or diesel-powered vans and SUVs.

Michael Brooks, govt director of the nonprofit Heart for Automotive Security, stated he, too, is worried concerning the weight of electrical autos as a result of patrons appear to be demanding 300 miles or extra on a single cost, which requires heavy batteries.

Making a charging community for this might be a safety mistake, Brooks stated.

“These large and heavy batteries will do extra harm,” he stated. “It is only a matter of mass and velocity.”

Brooks stated he’s conscious of a small quantity of analysis on the protection dangers related to elevated car weight. In 2011, the Nationwide Bureau of Financial Analysis printed an article stating that being hit by a automotive with 1,000 kilos of additional weight will increase your likelihood of dying in a crash by 47%.

He notes that electrical autos have very excessive energy, which permits them to speed up rapidly even in crowded city areas. “Persons are not skilled to cope with such acceleration. It is simply not what drivers are used to,” Brooks stated.

As well as, many new electrical SUVs have excessive heights and restricted visibility, posing a danger to pedestrians or drivers of small autos, he stated.

Gross sales of recent electrical autos within the US rose almost 65% ​​final yr to 807,000 — about 5.8% of all new car gross sales. The Biden administration has set a aim of electrical autos reaching 50% of recent automotive gross sales by 2030 and is providing tax credit of as much as $7,500 to attain this. Consulting agency LMC Automotive has made a extra modest forecast: by 2030, electrical autos will account for a 3rd of the brand new automotive market.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.